It must be the end of summer, the silly season, and a time when even the bare knuckles-first Church of Scientology gets a sense of humor. The NYT reported that people were distributing outside the magazine offices copies of a parody title looking faintly like the original: "The New Yorker: What a Load of Balderdash." This was a response to an exhaustive February 2011 article that according to the Times painted the Church "as corrupt and cultish." That it did but with 26-pages to play with, TNY actually offered a lengthy, balanced, and nuanced view of the organization, often using its own language, teachings, and apostates to tell the story. It has the tension, tone, and narrative progression one expects from the magazine. This after all is about the struggle for mind and soul.
Actually I read the article after I had read the parody and accompanying videos at http://www.freedommag.org/. The parody itself is quite funny and the mock New Yorker cover works. The video version has symbolic flies or gnats buzzing around the cover image, suggesting that the Church is the gnat that will peck at the media giant. In the various videos that take TNY fact checkers to task, there are background scenes from Western bar fight movies, overwrought dramas, and probably the Three Stooges. TNY is described as no better than a supermarket tabloid. A fake cover shouts: "Remnick Denies Alien Baby Claims." TNY editor David Remnick will not lose much sleep over this.
The Church should have stopped while it was ahead. The endless lamentations about the magazine fact-checkers, the ad hominen pokes, the scorched earth policy when dealing with apostates, hands a trunkload of weapons to those who reside on the other side of the Amen altar.
Friday, September 2, 2011
Friday, August 19, 2011
Magazines & Depth Psychology
Yes, I realize the above title might be considered an oxymoron given the content of many lifestyle magazines. To be sure, there is much popular psychology in men's and women's magazines these days and that is probably just about right in a world driven by bumps, grinds, and tweets. It was not always the case.
I came across a few pages from "The New Eve: A Magazine of Feminine Charm" from December 1926 and 'Mademoiselle: The Magazine for Smart Young Women" dated September 1943. Eve focused on society, fashions, sports and theatres. Mademoiselle seemed to pay most attention to brides and fall fashions, in this instance.
1943 is wartime and the cover shows a sailor with his hat off sitting at the desk of a towering executive woman, perhaps asking for a job or recruiting her, which seems unlikely. Chesterfied supports the war and the cigarette advertisement that has a banner stating America Needs Nurses---Enlist Now, also shows three nurses smoking. And promotes "So Proudly We Hail" a war movie epic about nurses featuring Claudette Colbert, Paulette Goddard, and Veronica Lake.
In tone and spirit these titles contain the elements of contemporary women's magazines. Eve actually contains "An Editorial for Advertisers" that sketches the demographic shifts from the flapper to the new woman, in the kind of breezy language that would please advertisers. But this does not sound like "church vs. state" stuff. It seems more like an early 20th century magazine trying to find its way.
What most struck me about these magazines were the analytical psychology articles written by M. Esther Harding, MD, an influential Jungian psychologist. a student and friend of Carl Jung, and an analyst profoundly important to the adoption of Jungian psychology in the US. An article "Till You Meet Again" describes war time romances and the dangers of projection, building up illusions, and not establishing psychological boundaries to protect oneself.
In an article in Eve Dr. Harding psychoanalyzes a play 'The Captive." The editor in her note sets up the analysis by suggesting that the "performance is something akin to an agony of tense silence" and the audience leaves subdued, chastened and wondering. So there must be something more to the play than its objective plot.
Harding explores the archetypal implications of a Mother fixation and a male tendency to want a lover idealized and "harmonious" like the mother but at the same time hungers for the other woman representing the vulgar, of a lower class than his own.
These observations have spawned an industry.
Monday, August 8, 2011
Now the Unsexy ARPU
Online metrics used to be easy, until they didn't mean anything and became little more than competitive hammers in the marketplace.
Metrics are becoming hot again mainly because so many IPOs are coming to market. In his column for the Nieman Journalism Lab Ken Doctor takes a knife (and fork) to this fantasy world of online metrics (www.niemanlab.org/2011/08/the-newsonomics-of-arpu). He mentions Groupon's foggy metrics and balance sheet nonsense: "adjusted consolidated segment operating income." He also cites the Huffington Post claims to have surpassed the New York Times in online traffic.
Doctor suggests that publishers add another metric to the mix: Average Revenue Per User (ARPU), as the telcos and cable TV have done for years, to change the focus from customers or visitors to how much money we are making. By his back-of-the envelope analysis each unique NYT customer in 2010 was worth about $3.54; the Huffington Post about $.96.
In this tale of the tape "unique visitors are a great dumb count." In the future he sees a mobile ARPU,a smartphone ARPU, and so on.
In the last year I have been working closely with network operators.
I think they can teach publishers a few things about digital business models and metrics.
Tablets & the Value Proposition
There are hockey sticks and then there is tablet growth. According to ABI Research more than 17 million tablets shipped in 2010. The firm expects 46 million tablets to be shipped in 2011 and an estimated 126 million media tablets to be shipped worldwide in 2016.
Only three media tablet vendors can claim shipments of more than 2% in 2010. Apple led the pack with 85% of all shipments with Samsung at 8% and Archos at 2%. Or 95% of all products. Apple's market share might have dropped below 75% so far in 2011, but no one is likely to match Apple's appeal.
So what happened to the 80-plus media tablets we saw at CES in 2011? Not surprisingly, many of these tablets were from first-time vendors who were trying to differentiate product mainly by price. According to ABI this strategy could lead to a "netbook" effect, meaning end-users expectations are set higher than what products deliver. "Should this occur with media tablets, market demand will cool and hinder the transition from early adopters to the early majority."
ABI suggests fragmentation within the OS software will hinder growth of this device category. As we know application develops must choose an initial software platform. If the market upside is not significant, application development might be delayed. "The benefits of open software platform development have yet to be realized for media tablets."
While some of my publisher friends have privately stated that the tablet game is over with the Apple anointing and Samsung declared a worthy #2, the pesky eco-systems rules that the ODMs and OEMs live and die by suggest that the tablet value proposition remains unclear.
Monday, August 1, 2011
Time Magazine--Digital Genius
L2, a think tank for digital innovation, has provided publishers with a huge service in rating the web efforts of the top titles.
In his introduction to the "Digital IQ Index" Scott Galloway, Founder L2 and Clinical Professor of Marketing, NYU Stern, reminds us that "There is no shortage of smarts or innovation in the magazine business. However, even with the total advertising down more than 20% from its pre-financial crisis peak, no company or individual has been able to paint a cogent picture of what the industry's next interation will look, smell or feel like."
Galloway notes that online CPMs dropped 30% in the 12-month period ending March 2011. He adds that the iPad has not lived up to its hype and "as of December 2010 all magazines reporting data experienced declining digital edition sales."
On the bright side: "In 2011 the amount of paid content traveling through the ether surpassed free content and several pay walls appear to be gaining traction." The researcher cites PwC analysts who have suggested that by 2015 annual digital circulation revenues associated with magazines could grow to $611 million by 2015."
The L2 study attempts to quantity and rank the digital competence of 87 top magazine brands. The study also explores the relationship between digital savvy and ad revenue per page. The end game here is to provide publishers with tools to help better quantify return on incremental digital investment. This has been a decade-long lament; pouring significant investments into online efforts but not always having a clear sense of return.
I'll dig deeper into how this range of magazine online brands rate in my next post. The point I'd like to make here is that most digital innovation and business advances are coming from the larger companies with the resources to take strategic bets. It is not surprising Time magazine rates at the Genius end of the spectrum and is rated #1 in this study and is in four of the top ten positions.
In the language of the study: Time magazine has a"strong presence across nearly every platform; inspiring."
This is good news for everyone.
In his introduction to the "Digital IQ Index" Scott Galloway, Founder L2 and Clinical Professor of Marketing, NYU Stern, reminds us that "There is no shortage of smarts or innovation in the magazine business. However, even with the total advertising down more than 20% from its pre-financial crisis peak, no company or individual has been able to paint a cogent picture of what the industry's next interation will look, smell or feel like."
Galloway notes that online CPMs dropped 30% in the 12-month period ending March 2011. He adds that the iPad has not lived up to its hype and "as of December 2010 all magazines reporting data experienced declining digital edition sales."
On the bright side: "In 2011 the amount of paid content traveling through the ether surpassed free content and several pay walls appear to be gaining traction." The researcher cites PwC analysts who have suggested that by 2015 annual digital circulation revenues associated with magazines could grow to $611 million by 2015."
The L2 study attempts to quantity and rank the digital competence of 87 top magazine brands. The study also explores the relationship between digital savvy and ad revenue per page. The end game here is to provide publishers with tools to help better quantify return on incremental digital investment. This has been a decade-long lament; pouring significant investments into online efforts but not always having a clear sense of return.
I'll dig deeper into how this range of magazine online brands rate in my next post. The point I'd like to make here is that most digital innovation and business advances are coming from the larger companies with the resources to take strategic bets. It is not surprising Time magazine rates at the Genius end of the spectrum and is rated #1 in this study and is in four of the top ten positions.
In the language of the study: Time magazine has a"strong presence across nearly every platform; inspiring."
This is good news for everyone.
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
The Gang of Four
Google's Executive Chairman Eric Schmidt spoke recently about the new gang of four that includes Apple (devices), Facebook (social), Amazon (commerce) and Google (search.) Though these businesses are migrating into companion spaces, they are all robust platforms in their own right.
What actually caught my attention was his remark that together these companies are valued at about half a trillion dollars, give or take. This is on the same day that Hearst is said to be closing its just-under-a-billion dollar purchase of Hachette. No wonder there is a growing chorus about another digital bubble.
I will agree that digital valuations are over-the-top (the no revenue Flipboard valued at $200 million?) but I don't see a digital bubble. This is not 1998 all over again. The fact remains that the tech companies mentioned above, and many others, are sitting on tons of cash and take huge risks with it. Publishers, not so much.
Russell Adams had an interesting piece yesterday in the WSJ, interviewing CEO Chuck Townsend on the new business model at Conde Nast. The interview was sober and illustrative of the challenges facing the magazine industry. When asked whether we should expect a big, splashy acquisition, Townsend responded, "Zero chance of that." He also acknowledged that an acquisiton on the order of the $325 million Hearst paid for iCrossing, a digital advertising firm, was not likely. He did acknowledge some regret about not going after Glam.com, an "obvious misfire."
The "gang of four" mentioned above also happen to be partners to publishers. Ten years after the tech onslaught, content remains a huge differentiator. The current tech landscape has forced many publishers to focus on agnostic digital content channels that can scale, protect the brand, be monetized and provide data. This is absolutely the right business approach and will become more meaningful when the previous conditions are met. That remains the rub.
Publishers should be hard-nose about where they go with their content but in this climate, deeper relationsips with tech companies are both necessary and inevitable. Publishers can't go it alone. They can't build or buy their way into a digital future of consequence.
This will come through tech partnerships.
What actually caught my attention was his remark that together these companies are valued at about half a trillion dollars, give or take. This is on the same day that Hearst is said to be closing its just-under-a-billion dollar purchase of Hachette. No wonder there is a growing chorus about another digital bubble.
I will agree that digital valuations are over-the-top (the no revenue Flipboard valued at $200 million?) but I don't see a digital bubble. This is not 1998 all over again. The fact remains that the tech companies mentioned above, and many others, are sitting on tons of cash and take huge risks with it. Publishers, not so much.
Russell Adams had an interesting piece yesterday in the WSJ, interviewing CEO Chuck Townsend on the new business model at Conde Nast. The interview was sober and illustrative of the challenges facing the magazine industry. When asked whether we should expect a big, splashy acquisition, Townsend responded, "Zero chance of that." He also acknowledged that an acquisiton on the order of the $325 million Hearst paid for iCrossing, a digital advertising firm, was not likely. He did acknowledge some regret about not going after Glam.com, an "obvious misfire."
The "gang of four" mentioned above also happen to be partners to publishers. Ten years after the tech onslaught, content remains a huge differentiator. The current tech landscape has forced many publishers to focus on agnostic digital content channels that can scale, protect the brand, be monetized and provide data. This is absolutely the right business approach and will become more meaningful when the previous conditions are met. That remains the rub.
Publishers should be hard-nose about where they go with their content but in this climate, deeper relationsips with tech companies are both necessary and inevitable. Publishers can't go it alone. They can't build or buy their way into a digital future of consequence.
This will come through tech partnerships.
Tuesday, May 31, 2011
Fear and Grumbling (Again)
It was only a decade ago that a senior executive at Hachette asked me how to spell dot com. The same executive was not displeased when the Internet bubble arrived, as scheduled. Mr. X had learned enough that he could, after April 2001, deliver luncheon speeches about how he had predicted its demise. So good was he in this role that he found a place in my soon-to-be published novel. In this iteration the character builds paper mache Internet monsters that look like a many-headed hydra so he could kill them with a very real sword in front of a foot-stomping crowd of magazine publishers chanting "print today, print tomorrow, print forever."
I thought I was safe in my fictional cul-de-sac. After all, magazine publishers, blindsided by the Internet have given in the last five years or so every indication they are getting it or at least struggling with the emerging platforms and channels and placing strategic bets. This new generation of digital executives are not contributing very much to my fictional needs.
Then along comes Jann Wenner, founder and publisher of Rolling Stone and other titles, who was quoted in Ad Age suggesting the rush to the iPad is "sheer insanity and insecurity and fear." Like my fictional character Mr. Wenner seems not to be very knowledgeable about the Internet and magazine companies in that space, including Forbes. Appropriately Forbes reminded him that the magazine gets more revenue from digital than print. And that if Rolling Stone had a decent web site the magazine could have gotten much more benefit from the infamous General McCrystal article.
If I had completed my training in psychology, I would suggest that Mr. Wenner doesn't really mean what he says; he's just addressing the shadow side of the business, where there is much concern about technology but, from what I can tell, little insanity. But to continue the metaphor: we come to grips with our shadow side--or technology--by embracing and understanding it. In this respect magazines have done a fairly good job.
I am heartened by digital hires from outside the magazine space and, if I can put it this way, the collective rise in digital intelligence. But with all the good news I remain convinced that most tech developments in publishing will come from outside the ranks. Blogger Frederic Filloux addresses the need for tech and media companies to work together. In his view media companies have lost the dual battle for growth and economic performance. Tech companies have the audience and endless funding. (www.mondaynote.com/2011/05/22/media-tech-reconcilability).
I just returned from the SID (display) conference in Los Angeles and was reminded of how little I really knew about the software side of e-readers, smartphones and tablets. I was also reminded of the numerous conversations I have had with publishers who are overwhelmed with the number of devices, OS, and interfaces available. They seem to want a simpler, more predictable eco-system.
My response to this understandable desire is that the fragmentation will likely become more pronounced as the competition, especially in the tablet arena, heats up. My suggestion: move beyond the pure aesthetic of these devices and deeper into the raw technologies and in this way invite conversations with the ODMs, OEMs, and carriers, starting at the "chip level."
Mr. X is waiting in the wings.
I thought I was safe in my fictional cul-de-sac. After all, magazine publishers, blindsided by the Internet have given in the last five years or so every indication they are getting it or at least struggling with the emerging platforms and channels and placing strategic bets. This new generation of digital executives are not contributing very much to my fictional needs.
Then along comes Jann Wenner, founder and publisher of Rolling Stone and other titles, who was quoted in Ad Age suggesting the rush to the iPad is "sheer insanity and insecurity and fear." Like my fictional character Mr. Wenner seems not to be very knowledgeable about the Internet and magazine companies in that space, including Forbes. Appropriately Forbes reminded him that the magazine gets more revenue from digital than print. And that if Rolling Stone had a decent web site the magazine could have gotten much more benefit from the infamous General McCrystal article.
If I had completed my training in psychology, I would suggest that Mr. Wenner doesn't really mean what he says; he's just addressing the shadow side of the business, where there is much concern about technology but, from what I can tell, little insanity. But to continue the metaphor: we come to grips with our shadow side--or technology--by embracing and understanding it. In this respect magazines have done a fairly good job.
I am heartened by digital hires from outside the magazine space and, if I can put it this way, the collective rise in digital intelligence. But with all the good news I remain convinced that most tech developments in publishing will come from outside the ranks. Blogger Frederic Filloux addresses the need for tech and media companies to work together. In his view media companies have lost the dual battle for growth and economic performance. Tech companies have the audience and endless funding. (www.mondaynote.com/2011/05/22/media-tech-reconcilability).
I just returned from the SID (display) conference in Los Angeles and was reminded of how little I really knew about the software side of e-readers, smartphones and tablets. I was also reminded of the numerous conversations I have had with publishers who are overwhelmed with the number of devices, OS, and interfaces available. They seem to want a simpler, more predictable eco-system.
My response to this understandable desire is that the fragmentation will likely become more pronounced as the competition, especially in the tablet arena, heats up. My suggestion: move beyond the pure aesthetic of these devices and deeper into the raw technologies and in this way invite conversations with the ODMs, OEMs, and carriers, starting at the "chip level."
Mr. X is waiting in the wings.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)